Is this a Crisis of Consciousness or a Crisis of Meaning?

David Kracov's Book of Life

David Kracov’s Book of Life

I have studied consciousness extensively throughout my life. I studied neurophysiology at university as part of my degree in psychology, which was heavily based around cognitive psychology, and then again during my masters degree when I studied the question of wholeness as it relates to quantum physics, consciousness and our being in the world.

Consciousness is one of those tricky words which everyone knows the meaning of until it is time to define it, and then it all goes belly up. It still remains a mystery to most, and no sooner has someone developed a ‘theory of consciousness’ that many others come along to pick holes and find flaws.

The word consciousness is coming up more and more in many areas, such as conscious capitalism, conscious consumption, and this is great. In this sense, the word is very related to conscientiousness, and the desire to do good and find a deeper purpose to life than one which simply flatters and serves our egos.

Credit: Simon Robinson

Credit: Simon Robinson

If you look at how we work with consciousness in our book Holonomics, is is related to a journey into meaning. This is a monumentally difficult journey, since it requires a heroic effort to cross the threshold of liminality, a point in life where all our known concepts and understandings have broken down, but where new ways of seeing have not yet been constructed.

So while I mentioned that this notion of consciousness is now permeating our collective consciousness more and more, at the same time there are some related trends such as the explosion of gurudom and guruitis, which are the inevitable side-effect of a society which is moving away from traditional work patterns and into the dog-eat-dog competitive world of freelancing, where there is a continual need to differentiate oneself in the sharing economy. Ironic huh?

If we look, somewhat self-knowingly pretentiously, at the ontology of the guru, we can ask ourselves the question what exactly is the world view of the guru, and what are they really trying to say to us? I don’t know about you, but this for me is an extremely important question.

There are many gurus who in fact actually just want to be leaders with followers. And so their search is a search for followers, and in this search their claim is that they have unique access to the truth. This is different to the traditional role of the guru which was to facilitate the journey through the point of liminality into a deeper understanding of self and reality.

Gadamer Truth and Method

Photo: Simon Robinson

So what is my own path through all of this?

Well I am interested in the question of being, a philosophical question which I find no need to apologise for. And where I have found great words of wisdom is in the hermeneutical teachings of Hans-Georg Gadamer, and in the expression of Gadamer’s phenomenological hermeneutics by Henri Bortoft.

Prof. Hans-Georg Gadamer in seinem Heidelberger Arbeitszimmer

Prof. Hans-Georg Gadamer in seinem Heidelberger Arbeitszimmer

Gadamer’s great quest in life was to understand interpretation, and for Gadamer interpretation itself has a specific meaning which is not necessarily that of the common-sense meaning most of us use. We as human beings have interpretation deeply embedded into our very meaning, we are interpreting beings, and obviously a great part of this is the role language plays in our conception of reality.

We can create a continuum of theories of language, where on one extreme language is seen as constructing or giving meaning to reality, and at the other extreme reality is seen as something which humans are able to intuitively understand without any mediation at all of language.

Gadamer takes neither of these positions, rather seeing a dynamic relationship between language and reality, whereby language both has the ability to disclose reality to us, but also conceals it to us in limiting our understandings to certain contexts. This does not need to be a trap, since if we expand our level of consciousness we become more open to deeper experiences of reality, while not believing we have the final and ultimate explanation of truth.

As Bruce Wachterhauser says in Beyond Being, “language is an indispensable place where the intelligibility of the real makes itself manifest”.

This leads us to Gadamer’s conception of the unfinished meaning of a work of art, a text or performance (of any variety). Meaning is neither one of free interpretation open to any subjective whim, but neither is it dogmatically closed, or ultimately definable, reachable and defined only by an intellectual elite.

Credit: Simon Robinson

Credit: Simon Robinson

So ultimately, what can we conclude? Is our current global predicament that we find ourselves in one of consciousness, or is it really the fact that we are struggling to really connect with each other through a shared meaning? Is it the case that we struggle to understand the fullest meaning of our thoughts, words and actions? If this is the case, consciousness is the path and meaning is the real purpose.

Related Articles
10 Reasons You Should Read Gadamer’s Truth and Method

5 responses to “Is this a Crisis of Consciousness or a Crisis of Meaning?

  1. “A crisis of consciousness or of meaning?”

    I’d say it is both. Two sides of the same coin, like left and right, or up and down.

    The crisis we face is that we have mis-understood the world (consciously), which has led to a failure to achieve our true purpose (and meaning).

    Those failures have led to an existential / psychological crisis (failure to achieve purpose/meaning) and a physical / sustainability crisis (because the way we consciously understand the world does not match with the way the world actually works).

    The one drives the other, and each provides the opportunity to resolve the other.

    The solution is to build a repeating cycle of a) uncovering our purpose as best we can understand it now, b) implementing that and learning from the experience.

    This is why I am writing The Churning. To enable people to find and implement their purpose, and simultaneously their consciousness, without the need for a ‘guru’.

  2. Hi Finn,
    Exactly, sometimes it seems to me that words chop up reality and it takes conscious effort to stay within our lived experience of reality rather than jump back into an analytical experience.

    • I totally agree with you Simon. 🙂
      It is difficult to see reality as it truly is. But this is the problem we face, and the solution. 🙂

  3. Pingback: Stepping into the Fire | Transition Consciousness·

  4. Pingback: Setting Out Clearly the Challenge for Web 4.0 Search and Social | Transition Consciousness·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s